One Good Bottle: Caribbean RumThis clean, smooth, buttery aged spirit is made by a family that’s been distilling rum for 250 years.

The first time I uncorked an aged rum, it was a terrible mistake. I was at my girlfriend's grandparents' place, and I wanted a drink. So I opened a random bottle from their cabinet. The first sip puzzled me: it was as caramel-like as a good brandy. But it wasn't brandy. I called a liquor store and read the guy the label: "Añejo, Havana, Cuba, 1957." "You could have auctioned that off for a lot of money," he said. The bottle contained pre-Castro aged rum, and as I later found out, my girlfriend's great-uncle, Philip Bonsal, had been the U.S. ambassador to Cuba under President Dwight D. Eisenhower; I'd ruined an heirloom. I couldn't stomach another sip. We gave it away to a Cuban friend, and I tried to forget about it—that is, until I tasted Cruzan Single Barrel Rum ($32). Though it's born of a distinct distilling tradition, this rum from St. Croix, a U.S. Virgin Island, has a flavor and pedigree that reminds me of the ill-fated Cuban añejo. Cruzan distiller Gary Nelthropp's family has been making rum in St. Croix since 1760, and this copper-hued blend of four- to 12-year-old rums aged together in American white oak embodies the refinement that comes with a deep heritage. It's clean, smooth, and not too sweet, with a velvety feel and notes of butter, vanilla, and coconut. You can mix it like brandy; it's delicious in a sidecar. Or you can sip it neat—perhaps while recounting past exploits that are, hopefully, less embarrassing than mine.

Drinks

One Good Bottle: Caribbean Rum

This clean, smooth, buttery aged spirit is made by a family that’s been distilling rum for 250 years.

By Betsy Andrews


Published on March 9, 2010

The first time I uncorked an aged rum, it was a terrible mistake. I was at my girlfriend's grandparents' place, and I wanted a drink. So I opened a random bottle from their cabinet. The first sip puzzled me: it was as caramel-like as a good brandy. But it wasn't brandy. I called a liquor store and read the guy the label: "Añejo, Havana, Cuba, 1957." "You could have auctioned that off for a lot of money," he said. The bottle contained pre-Castro aged rum, and as I later found out, my girlfriend's great-uncle, Philip Bonsal, had been the U.S. ambassador to Cuba under President Dwight D. Eisenhower; I'd ruined an heirloom. I couldn't stomach another sip. We gave it away to a Cuban friend, and I tried to forget about it—that is, until I tasted Cruzan Single Barrel Rum ($32). Though it's born of a distinct distilling tradition, this rum from St. Croix, a U.S. Virgin Island, has a flavor and pedigree that reminds me of the ill-fated Cuban añejo. Cruzan distiller Gary Nelthropp's family has been making rum in St. Croix since 1760, and this copper-hued blend of four- to 12-year-old rums aged together in American white oak embodies the refinement that comes with a deep heritage. It's clean, smooth, and not too sweet, with a velvety feel and notes of butter, vanilla, and coconut. You can mix it like brandy; it's delicious in a sidecar. Or you can sip it neat—perhaps while recounting past exploits that are, hopefully, less embarrassing than mine.

Continue to Next Story

Want more SAVEUR?

Get our favorite recipes, stories, and more delivered to your inbox.